diy solar

diy solar

Battery fire safety

WOW I am so glad the OP raised this topic. It seems that a lot of DIY constructors are unaware of the consequences of a LiB going ape.
Ive just seen an astonishing vid
made from a conference of Fire safety professionals and presented by a a leading expert Professor of 20 + years studying the risks of Lithium battery cells to the public. I though I was being super careful and have realised I need to go one level further and move all such cells out of my house to an outdoor open space as the consequences of getting it wrong are disastrous and battery fires cant be extinguished. I will not be meddling with LiBs indoors anymore - strictly outdoors testing. If one cell goes goes critical it can burn your house down.

Watch this video and make up you own minds - I feel totally chastened and humbled by my own lack of appreciation of what can happen
 
WOW I am so glad the OP raised this topic. It seems that a lot of DIY constructors are unaware of the consequences of a LiB going ape.
Ive just seen an astonishing vid
made from a conference of Fire safety professionals and presented by a a leading expert Professor of 20 + years studying the risks of Lithium battery cells to the public. I though I was being super careful and have realised I need to go one level further and move all such cells out of my house to an outdoor open space as the consequences of getting it wrong are disastrous and battery fires cant be extinguished. I will not be meddling with LiBs indoors anymore - strictly outdoors testing. If one cell goes goes critical it can burn your house down.

Watch this video and make up you own minds - I feel totally chastened and humbled by my own lack of appreciation of what can happen
He speaks like it’s a common event, the probability of this is less than you being killed in a car accident
 
The OP is for the purpose of sharing usage experience and generating informed opinion. Of course there is the often opposing view that ignorance is bliss and better to be uninformed and claim plausible deniability (a popular position adopted by polititions no doubt)
Feel free to ignore the OP if its of no personal interest but at least allow members to make up their own minds
 
Herbert Williams fire extinguishers has some automatic clasd b that might help with stopping a fire before its a problem.
 
It would be interesting to see a small extinguisher bomb that would fit inside a LFP case - activated only in event of high temp.
Perhaps it would be better to have a back-up to the BMS control, cut off circuit if any cell temp exceeds a set-point value.
Maybe both.
 
Like a class b foam in a bag over the batteries that would rupture when exposed to flame?
 
Like a class b foam in a bag over the batteries that would rupture when exposed to flame?
Maybe, I am not sure what Class B foam is, but at least the idea of a material that will automatically respond to the issue - inside the cases.

I wonder:
If the BMS is the safety device we rely upon to cut off charging when a cell voltage gets too high, or pack temp gets too high, and we worry that a BMS failure could lead to a Pack failure and fire,
Then, should a battery pack really have two series-connected BMS's in case one fails?

In the event one BMS fails the other will continue to protect the pack, and provide the operator time to see a fault and repair the faulty BMS?
{If your brakes fail, you have the emergency brake as a back up?}
 
An idea for your consideration:
  • a cement board cabinet with a metal frame vented at the bottom. Figure 6" of clearance around the the pack. Sheath in cement board inside and outside of the frame for two burn through layers.
  • An oven vent/hood above with a chimney pipe out above the battery pack. If equipped, the fan thermostat could be set to kick on at 10% above maximum rated operating temperature to help cool packs getting warm or vent the presumably hot gasses leaking out of the packs.
  • The exterior of the chimney has some type of spark arrester screen like most modern chimney's
  • In the event of an "event", the heat flow (or worse flame) goes up the chimney and is exhausted outside of the structure. Even if the fire damages the fan, the air current should keep most of the heat and gasses going up and out of the chimney.
This simple arrangement would not cost much relative to fire damage and would go a long way to "contain" an unfortunate event.
 
An idea for your consideration:
  • a cement board cabinet with a metal frame vented at the bottom. Figure 6" of clearance around the the pack. Sheath in cement board inside and outside of the frame for two burn through layers.
  • An oven vent/hood above with a chimney pipe out above the battery pack. If equipped, the fan thermostat could be set to kick on at 10% above maximum rated operating temperature to help cool packs getting warm or vent the presumably hot gasses leaking out of the packs.
  • The exterior of the chimney has some type of spark arrester screen like most modern chimney's
  • In the event of an "event", the heat flow (or worse flame) goes up the chimney and is exhausted outside of the structure. Even if the fire damages the fan, the air current should keep most of the heat and gasses going up and out of the chimney.
This simple arrangement would not cost much relative to fire damage and would go a long way to "contain" an unfortunate event.
And a 20kW heater to keep the vented space warm during 6-months of winter, so the ESS stays warm enough to operate.

yeah, I know, not everyone lives in a cold place.

The fire rated enclosure seems like a good start, but rather than vents and chimney outlet, I think we are better off to seal it tight to contain the 'event' and add smoke and heat detectors to warn us of problems, hopefully before the situation gets out of hand.
I have smoke and heat detectors next to my ESS that alarm in my house (next door) but what I have been thinking of adding is an automatic disconnect tied to the two detectors - to cut off the ESS circuits to interrupt the flow of electricity at the first sign ot smoke or heat.
 
And a 20kW heater to keep the vented space warm during 6-months of winter, so the ESS stays warm enough to operate.

yeah, I know, not everyone lives in a cold place.

The fire rated enclosure seems like a good start, but rather than vents and chimney outlet, I think we are better off to seal it tight to contain the 'event' and add smoke and heat detectors to warn us of problems, hopefully before the situation gets out of hand.
I have smoke and heat detectors next to my ESS that alarm in my house (next door) but what I have been thinking of adding is an automatic disconnect tied to the two detectors - to cut off the ESS circuits to interrupt the flow of electricity at the first sign ot smoke or heat.
I've never seen a one size fits all solution for anything (that really works). Not living in that environment, I couldn't comment. I'm in an environment that will be concerned with batteries staying below their maximum operating temps. My building where my system is headed stays above freezing if the outside is above 0F.
 
I've never seen a one size fits all solution for anything (that really works). Not living in that environment, I couldn't comment. I'm in an environment that will be concerned with batteries staying below their maximum operating temps. My building where my system is headed stays above freezing if the outside is above 0F.
Agreed,
Especially with a forum like this one with members spanning a good portion of the globe and all the local conditions that come with that.
 
Back
Top